NCIER®

Behaviors Of Concern

104 claims on pp. 7–95 (fact 17, statement 39, evidence 30, conclusion 1, conjecture 4, definition 13).

Claims about Behaviors Of Concern

Definition [V] p007-04

Individual of concern: concerning behaviors that may signal potential harm

An individual of concern is anyone who has exhibited concerning behaviors that may indicate a potential risk of harm to themselves or others in the workplace setting.

Any individual who has exhibited concerning behaviors that may indicate a potential risk of harm to themselves or others in the workplace setting.

p. 7 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 7 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 7 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p007-05

Concerning behavior is troubling conduct indicating potential violence risk

Concerning behavior is action or communication that is objectively or contextually troubling or inappropriate and indicates a potential risk of violence.

Actions or communications by an individual that are objectively or contextually troubling or inappropriate and indicate a potential risk of violence.

p. 7 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 7 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 7 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p009-07

Violence prevention includes recognizing and reporting concerning behaviors for many employees

For many employees, violence prevention includes recognizing and reporting concerning behaviors they observe so action can be taken before violence occurs.

For many employees, this includes recognizing and reporting concerning behaviors they observe so action can be taken to intervene before violence can occur.

p. 9 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 9 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 9 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p014-25

Mental health center attacker yelled and demanded the employee from his last visit

On arriving at the mental health treatment center, the attacker began to yell and insisted on seeing the employee he had seen on his last visit.

Upon arrival, he began to yell, and insisted that he see the employee he saw on his last visit.

p. 14 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 14 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 14 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p015-16

Key finding: 78% of attackers had a history of behaviors that elicited concern

The Key Findings for Attackers box states that 78% of attackers had a history of behaviors that elicited concern from others.

Sample (n = 40 of 51) · attackers, all affiliation types

78% of attackers had a history of behaviors that elicited concern from others.

p. 15 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 15 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 15 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p016-04

Other concerning behaviors: threats, strange conduct, stalking, harassment

Other behaviors that elicited concern included disturbing or threatening statements, strange or unusual behavior, and stalking and harassing others.

Other behaviors that elicited concern included attackers making disturbing or threatening statements, exhibiting strange or unusual behaviors, and stalking and harassing others.

p. 16 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 16 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 16 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p018-18

Grocery attacker made school-shooting videos and journaled admiration and attack plans

In the months before the attack, the grocery store attacker created and shared videos glorifying school shootings and wrote in numerous journal entries about his admiration of past attackers and his attack plans.

In the months prior to his attack, the attacker created and shared videos glorifying school shootings, and described his admiration of past attackers and his plans for his attack in numerous journal entries.

p. 18 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 18 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 18 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p019-09

Examples of concerning communications by employee attackers

One attacker accused his wife of spying for the government and made her write to him, then burned the pages. Another threatened coworkers at a cemetery, prompting his termination, and then complained about them for seven years.

For example, one attacker accused his wife of collaborating with the government to spy on him

p. 19 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 19 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 19 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p020-05

Table 5: performance and conduct of employee attackers

Table 5 gives work performance (good standing 6, 27%; substantive issues 8, 36%; unknown 8, 36%) and behavioral conduct (good standing 8, 36%; substantive issues 10, 45%, of which toxicity 7, 32%; unknown 4, 18%) of employee attackers.

Sample (N = 22) · current or former employee attackers (22 attacks, each by a lone attacker)

Table 5: Performance and Conduct

p. 20 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 20 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 20 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p020-07

45% of employee attackers had known substantive conduct issues (n = 10)

Over two-fifths of employee attackers (n = 10, 45%) had known substantive issues pertaining to their behavioral conduct at the workplace they attacked.

Sample (n = 10 of 22) · current or former employee attackers (22 attacks, each by a lone attacker)

Over two-fifths (n = 10, 45%) of employee attackers had known substantive issues pertaining to their behavioral conduct at the workplace they attacked.

p. 20 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 20 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 20 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p020-08

Behavioral conduct defined as workplace actions and adherence to standards

Behavioral conduct refers to actions taken by employees in the workplace, including how they interact with colleagues and whether they adhere to an organization's standards for behavior.

Behavioral conduct refers to actions taken by employees in the workplace, including how they interact with colleagues and others at work, and whether they adhere to an organization's policies or standards for behavior.

p. 20 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 20 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 20 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p020-09

Toxic conduct defined as persistent callous, aggressive, or threatening patterns

Toxic conduct shows persistent patterns of callous, reckless, paranoid, confrontational, aggressive, and/or threatening behaviors toward others.

persistent patterns of callous, reckless, paranoid, confrontational, aggressive, and/or threatening behaviors toward others

p. 20 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 20 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 20 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p020-13

Three attackers had non-toxic conduct issues such as chronic absences

Three attackers exhibited behaviors that were not considered toxic but still represented issues with conduct, including chronic absences or tardiness.

Three attackers exhibited behaviors that were not considered toxic but still represented issues with conduct, including chronic absences or tardiness.

p. 20 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 20 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 20 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p020-15

Confrontational ex-employee killed five former coworkers after firing

A 45-year-old gunman with a reputation for confrontation and fights at work, who had been fired two months earlier for stealing company equipment, opened fire at his former workplace and killed five former coworkers before dying by suicide. He had struggled financially and had asked to be rehired.

A 45-year-old gunman opened fire with a pistol at his former workplace, killing five of his former coworkers before dying by suicide.

p. 20 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 20 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 20 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p023-06

Key finding: 65% engaged in concerning behavior at the location before attacking

The key findings box reports that 65% engaged in concerning behaviors at the targeted location before their attack.

Sample (n = 13 of 20) · customer, client, patient, and visitor attackers

65% engaged in concerning behaviors at the targeted location prior to their attack

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p023-11

Nearly two-thirds (65%) of these attackers showed concerning behavior at the location

Nearly two-thirds (n = 13, 65%) of these attackers engaged in concerning or threatening behaviors at the targeted location before their attack.

Sample (n = 13 of 20) · customer, client, patient, and visitor attackers

Nearly two-thirds (n = 13, 65%) of the attackers who were known or knowable as customers, clients, patients, and visitors engaged in concerning or threatening behaviors at the targeted location prior to their attack

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p023-12

Prior concerning behaviors ranged from ejection for rudeness to threats to kill

Prior behaviors ranged from being ejected for erratic or rude conduct to threatening to harm or kill employees or other customers.

ranging from attackers who were ejected from the establishment due to erratic or rude behavior, to attackers who threatened to harm or kill employees or other customers

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p023-13

Newsroom attacker had harassed staff for years before opening fire

An attacker who opened fire in a newsroom office had harassed the newspaper's staff for years before the attack.

an attacker who opened fire in a newsroom office had been harassing the staff of the newspaper for years leading up to his attack

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p030-05

Individual of concern is anyone showing concerning behavior of potential harm

In the context of preventing workplace violence, an individual of concern is any individual who has exhibited concerning behaviors that may indicate a potential risk of harm to themselves or others in the workplace setting.

an individual of concern is any individual who has exhibited concerning behaviors that may indicate a potential risk of harm to themselves or others in the workplace setting.

p. 30 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 30 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 30 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p031-05

Acting on early concerning behavior improves chances of preventing violence

Acting at the first sign of concerning behavior, rather than waiting for a direct or explicit threat, improves the chances of preventing violence.

Acting at the first sign of concerning behavior, instead of waiting for a direct or explicit threat, improves the chances of preventing violence.

p. 31 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 31 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 31 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p040-05

A dedicated BTAM policy can support a more comprehensive prevention program

A dedicated BTAM policy can help create a more comprehensive prevention program capable of addressing a continuum of behaviors and concerns.

Having a dedicated policy for the BTAM program can help to create a more comprehensive prevention program capable of addressing a continuum of behaviors and concerns.

p. 40 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 40 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 40 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p041-03

Policy should state that BTAM covers behavior beyond explicit threats

The policy should articulate key BTAM principles, including that the program addresses any behavior indicating potential risk, not only explicit or direct threats.

state that the program encompasses work to proactively address any behavior that indicates a potential risk to safety and is not limited to explicit or direct threats.

p. 41 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 41 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 41 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p042-02

Policy should set when BTAM convenes and allow a low threshold of concern

The policy should set parameters for when the BTAM team convenes and responds to a report, and should allow a low threshold of concern.

Establish parameters for when the BTAM team will convene and respond to a report. The policy should allow for a low threshold of concern

p. 42 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 42 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 42 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p050-09

Definition: concerning behavior

Concerning behavior is an action or communication by an individual that is objectively or contextually troubling or inappropriate and indicates a potential risk of violence.

Actions or communications by an individual that are objectively or contextually troubling or inappropriate and indicate a potential risk of violence.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-11

Concerning behavior: escalating interpersonal disputes

Escalating interpersonal disputes are among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-12

Concerning behavior: grievances

Grievances are among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-13

Concerning behavior: concerning social media content

Concerning social media content is among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-14

Concerning behavior: stalking and harassment

Stalking and harassment are among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-15

Concerning behavior: obsessions with violence

Obsessions with violence are among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-16

Concerning behavior: idolizing past attackers

Idolizing past attackers is among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-17

Concerning behavior: fixating on people or locations

Fixating on people or locations is among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-18

Concerning behavior: suicidal ideations

Suicidal ideations are among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-19

Concerning behavior: self-harm

Self-harm is among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-20

Concerning behavior: unusual levels of aggression

Unusual levels of aggression are among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-21

Concerning behavior: threats

Threats are among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-22

Concerning behavior: weapons violations

Weapons violations are among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-23

Concerning behavior: physical assaults

Physical assaults are among the behaviors that may be concerning.

Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-24

Objectively concerning behaviors warrant immediate action

Objectively concerning behaviors such as unauthorized weapons, threats, and assaults should warrant immediate action, often including local law enforcement.

Some behaviors are objectively concerning (e.g., unauthorized weapons, threats, assaults) and should warrant immediate action, oftentimes including local law enforcement intervention.

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p050-25

Contextually concerning behaviors should be assessed in full context

Contextually concerning behaviors, such as rapidly deteriorating performance or angry outbursts, should be assessed in the full context of the person and environment.

Other behaviors are contextually concerning, in that they may not prompt immediate safety concerns but should be assessed in the full context of the individual's situation and their environment

p. 50 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 50 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 50 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p051-01

Figure 8 example: changes in behavior at work

Figure 8 lists, under Contextually Concerning, changes in behavior, including decreased productivity, increased absenteeism, decreased attention to personal hygiene and appearance, or withdrawal from social circles.

Changes in behavior, including decreased productivity, increased absenteeism, decreased attention to personal hygiene and appearance, or withdrawal from social circles

p. 51 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 51 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 51 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p051-05

Figure 8 example: questionable activity on work-issued devices

Figure 8 lists, under Contextually Concerning, questionable activity on work-issued devices, such as attempting to access prohibited sites or searching for inappropriate content.

Questionable activity on work-issued devices, such as attempting to access prohibited sites or searching for inappropriate content

p. 51 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 51 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 51 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p051-15

Employees should receive specific examples of concerning behavior

Employees should be given specific examples of the types of behavior that may prompt these concerns.

Employees should also be provided with specific examples of the types of behavior that may prompt these concerns.

p. 51 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 51 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 51 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p054-02

Organizations must keep a low threshold of concern

It is essential for organizations to keep a low threshold of concern and not limit focus solely to explicit threats of violence.

It is essential for organizations to maintain a low threshold of concern for initiating a behavioral threat assessment and not limit their focus solely to explicit threats of violence.

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p054-03

A low threshold lets teams act before violence is imminent

A low threshold of concern allows BTAM teams to identify individuals eliciting safety concerns before their behavior escalates to imminent risk of harm.

Utilizing a low threshold of concern allows BTAM teams to identify individuals eliciting safety concerns before their behavior escalates to the point where there is an imminent risk of harm.

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Conjecture [I] p054-05

Scenario behaviors may signal factors that could lead to harm

The scenario's behaviors may illustrate individual or environmental factors that, if unaddressed, could raise the possibility of harm to self or others.

may illustrate individual or environmental factors that, if unaddressed, could contribute to an increased possibility of harm to self or others

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map

Why inferred Hedged with 'may illustrate' and 'could contribute', so typed as conjecture.

Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p054-06

Use a low threshold for early intervention, not labeling

It is best practice to use a low threshold of concern during the BTAM process, not to label someone a potential threat, but to allow early intervention.

It is best practice to use a low threshold of concern during the BTAM process, not to label an individual as a potential threat, but to allow for early intervention.

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p054-12

Hypothetical employee: denied any problems with his recent performance

The employee said he did not know what the supervisor meant by the question and denied seeing any problems with his recent performance.

The employee remarked that he did not know what the supervisor meant by the question and denied seeing any problems with his recent performance.

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p054-13

Hypothetical employee: increasingly calls in sick and appears increasingly unkempt

In the weeks after the meeting, the employee began calling in sick with increasing frequency, and when he does come to work his appearance has become increasingly unkempt.

In the weeks since that meeting with his supervisor, the employee has begun to call in sick to work with increasing frequency, and when he does show up for work, his appearance has become increasingly unkempt.

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p056-03

Cyber and IT may set up alerts for anomalous digital behavior

Cybersecurity and IT professionals may set up mechanisms that alert the BTAM team to anomalous digital behaviors.

Cybersecurity and IT professionals may set up mechanisms to alert the BTAM team to anomalous digital behaviors

p. 56 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 56 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 56 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p056-04

Alerts may flag repeated blocked-site visits or unusual device log-ins

Alerts may flag employees who visit blocked or forbidden websites on multiple occasions or log onto devices at unusual times.

employees who visit blocked or forbidden websites on multiple occasions or log onto their devices at unusual times

p. 56 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 56 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 56 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p059-04

Workplace was the most common formal setting for observed concerning behavior

In Mass Attacks in Public Spaces: 2016-2020 (2023), NTAC found that the workplace was the most common formal setting in which concerning behavior was observed.

NTAC found that the workplace was the most common formal setting in which concerning behavior was observed

p. 59 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 59 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 59 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Conclusion [V] p063-02

Attackers showed concerning behavior at work, home and online beforehand

In many cases, attackers had demonstrated concerning behavior at work, at home, and online before their attack, but no program existed to examine these behaviors collectively.

In many cases, attackers had demonstrated concerning behavior at work, at home, and online before their attack

p. 63 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 63 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 63 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p064-12

Fictional employee case: supervisor, coworkers, and HR each report concerns

In the fictional software-company example, the Systems Approach surfaced a supervisor's report of a sharp decline in performance and demeanor, coworkers' reports that he said he might snap if things did not improve, and HR's report of a coworker's complaints about his rude and combative nature.

During their assessment, the BTAM team uses the Systems Approach to identify several concerns about the employee

p. 64 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 64 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 64 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p064-14

Fictional customer case: disruptive frequent customer posts ominous social media

In the fictional retail example, a frequent customer with a history of disruptive and concerning behaviors recently posted on social media alluding to something bad happening to the store.

A major retail outlet has a frequent customer with a history of disruptive and concerning behaviors who recently made posts on social media alluding to something bad happening to the store.

p. 64 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 64 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 64 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p067-09

Themes separate situational behavior from persistent escalating patterns

The themes allow teams to distinguish situational behaviors, such as temporary frustrations or poor communication, from more persistent, escalating patterns of concern.

these themes allow BTAM teams to distinguish between situational behaviors, such as temporary frustrations or poor communication, and more persistent, escalating patterns of concern

p. 67 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 67 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 67 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p069-01

Behavioral themes alone cannot predict violence but inform management

The presence of behavioral themes alone cannot predict whether an individual will become violent, but it will inform the final assessment and management strategies.

the presence of these behavioral themes alone cannot predict if an individual will become violent

p. 69 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 69 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 69 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p069-02

Concerning communications include threats in any medium

Concerning or threatening communications are violent, threatening, or disturbing communications conveyed verbally, in writing, electronically, online, or by other means.

Any violent, threatening, or disturbing communications which may be conveyed verbally

p. 69 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 69 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 69 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p069-03

Interest in violent topics includes weapons, gore and prior attacks

Interest in violent topics is an unusual or excessive interest in weapons, violence, gore, prior attacks, notorious killers, or other concerning topics.

An unusual or excessive interest in weapons, violence, gore, prior attacks, notorious killers, or other concerning topics

p. 69 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 69 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 69 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p069-05

History of violence covers prior physical violence against people or property

History of violence is prior physical violence against people, animals, or property, including assaults, domestic violence, animal cruelty, and arson.

Prior acts of physical violence against people, animals, or property

p. 69 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 69 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 69 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Conjecture [I] p069-06

Escalation from property crimes to crimes against persons may signal risk

A history of violence may reveal an escalation in aggression, such as moving from property crimes to crimes against persons.

A history of violence may reveal signs of an escalation in aggressive behavior, for example, moving from property crimes to crimes against persons

p. 69 · NCIER Claim Map

Why inferred Hedged with 'may reveal'; typed as conjecture.

Report page 69 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 69 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p069-07

Stalking, harassing or bullying is willful conduct that causes victims fear

Stalking, harassing, or bullying is a pattern of conduct that willfully and maliciously causes another to feel bullied, stalked, persecuted, threatened, or injured.

A pattern of conduct that willfully and maliciously causes another to feel bullied, stalked, persecuted, threatened, injured, or attacked

p. 69 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 69 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 69 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p069-08

Extreme beliefs advocate hate or violence or shape daily life

Extreme beliefs are ideological, political, or conspiratorial beliefs that advocate hate or violence, form the basis of a worldview, or significantly influence daily life.

Extreme ideological, political, or conspiratorial beliefs that advocate hate or violence

p. 69 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 69 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 69 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p069-09

Fascination with weapons and violence shown by stockpiling and violent media

Fascination with weapons and violence can be demonstrated through stockpiling or manufacturing weapons, being described as obsessed with weapons, consuming or producing violent or graphic media, and writing stories or lyrics indicating a desire to harm others.

Fascination with weapons and violence can be demonstrated in a variety of ways, including stockpiling or manufacturing weapons

p. 69 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 69 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 69 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p069-10

Extreme beliefs may rest on distorted facts or advocate bias-based violence

Extreme beliefs may be based on distortion of facts (e.g., conspiracy theories) or may advocate distrust, hatred, or the use of violence targeting others based on biases against a particular race, religion, national origin, sexual orientation, gender, or gender identity.

Extreme beliefs may be based on distortion of facts (e.g., conspiracy theories) or may advocate distrust, hatred, or the use of violence targeting others based on biases against a particular race, religion, national origin, sexual orientation, gender, or gender identity.

p. 69 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 69 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 69 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p069-11

Assessing risk centers on behaviors commonly observed in previous attackers

Central to assessing whether an individual poses a risk of targeted violence is understanding the nature of concerning behaviors commonly observed in previous attackers.

Central to assessing whether an individual poses a risk of targeted violence is understanding the nature of concerning behaviors commonly observed in previous attackers.

p. 69 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 69 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 69 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p073-08

Oct 2017 manufacturing-facility attack: paranoia after a physical assault

After his assault, the attacker was known to be paranoid, believing others were searching for him or out to get him.

In the aftermath of his assault, he was known to be paranoid, believing others were searching for him or out to get him.

p. 73 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 73 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 73 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p073-10

Oct 2017 manufacturing-facility attack: prior jobs ended in terminations for aggression

The attacker had a history of threatening and concerning behavior at previous jobs and was terminated from those positions because of aggressive behavior.

Additionally, the attacker had a history of threatening and concerning behaviors in his previous jobs and was terminated from these positions due to his aggressive behavior.

p. 73 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 73 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 73 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p073-11

Oct 2017 manufacturing-facility attack: prior arrest for choking a coworker

He was arrested for assaulting a coworker by placing him in a chokehold, dragging him outside, and throwing him to the ground hard enough to cause unconsciousness.

On one occasion, he was arrested for assaulting a coworker after he put the coworker in a chokehold, dragged him outside, and threw him to the ground so hard that the coworker lost consciousness.

p. 73 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 73 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 73 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p076-04

Evaluation should track compliance, engagement, and changes in behavior

The team should consider whether the individual is complying with interventions, engaging with programming, and showing changes in mood, mental state, or behavior.

The BTAM team should also consider whether the individual is complying with interventions, engaging with programming, and exhibiting any changes in mood, mental state, or behavior.

p. 76 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 76 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 76 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p083-03

Issue written or verbal warnings stating concerns and expected behavior

Organizations should issue written or verbal warnings that state their concerns, behavioral expectations, and the actions that will follow if the behavior continues.

Issue written or verbal warnings to individuals to articulate the organization's concerns, expectations for the individual's behavior, and what actions the organization will take if the individual continues to engage in a concerning manner.

p. 83 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 83 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 83 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p085-08

Use behavioral agreements with patients who have shown aggression

Behavioral agreements with patients who have shown aggression can outline appropriate conduct and the consequences of violating the agreement.

Using behavioral agreements with patients who have exhibited aggression to outline appropriate behavioral conduct and consequences for violating the agreement.

p. 85 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 85 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 85 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Conjecture [I] p087-05

Checks may help identify patterns of hostile or violent behavior

When used appropriately, these strategies can be helpful in identifying patterns of hostile, concerning, inappropriate, criminal, or violent behaviors.

When used appropriately, these strategies can be helpful in identifying patterns of hostile, concerning, inappropriate, criminal, or violent behaviors.

p. 87 · NCIER Claim Map

Why inferred Hedged with 'can be helpful'; classified as conjecture.

Report page 87 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 87 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Conjecture [I] p087-09

Unaddressed problems may escalate to disruption or violence

If unaddressed, these problems can escalate, causing further disruption or even violence.

If unaddressed, these problems can escalate, causing further disruption or even violence.

p. 87 · NCIER Claim Map

Why inferred Hedged with 'can escalate'; classified as conjecture.

Report page 87 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 87 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p092-09

The publication offers research and guidance to intervene before violence occurs

The publication offers both research and guidance intended to help organizations and their partners recognize concerning behaviors and intervene before violence can occur.

This publication offers both research and guidance intended to help organizations and their partners recognize concerning behaviors and intervene before violence can occur.

p. 92 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 92 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 92 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p095-33

Concerning communications: all 75%, employees 77%, customers 65%, partners/relatives 89%

Data Table 2 reports concerning communications by 75% of all attackers (n = 51), 77% of current or former employees (n = 22), 65% of customers, clients, patients, and visitors (n = 20), and 89% of romantic partners and relatives (n = 9).

Sample (N = 51 | 22 | 20 | 9 by column) · Data Table 2 columns: all attackers 51 | employees 22 | customers, clients, patients, visitors 20 | partners and relatives 9

**Concerning Communications** | 75% | 77% | 65% | 89%

p. 95 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 95 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 95 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p095-42

Inappropriate interest in violence or weapons: all 10%, employees 9%, customers 10%, partners 11%

Data Table 2 reports an inappropriate interest in violence or weapons for 10% of all attackers (n = 51), 9% of current or former employees (n = 22), 10% of customers, clients, patients, and visitors (n = 20), and 11% of romantic partners and relatives (n = 9).

Sample (N = 51 | 22 | 20 | 9 by column) · Data Table 2 columns: all attackers 51 | employees 22 | customers, clients, patients, visitors 20 | partners and relatives 9

**Inappropriate Interest in Violence or Weapons** | 10% | 9% | 10% | 11%

p. 95 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 95 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 95 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p095-43

Behavior change: all 41%, employees 55%, customers 25%, partners/relatives 44%

Data Table 2 reports a behavior change for 41% of all attackers (n = 51), 55% of current or former employees (n = 22), 25% of customers, clients, patients, and visitors (n = 20), and 44% of romantic partners and relatives (n = 9).

Sample (N = 51 | 22 | 20 | 9 by column) · Data Table 2 columns: all attackers 51 | employees 22 | customers, clients, patients, visitors 20 | partners and relatives 9

**Behavior Change** | 41% | 55% | 25% | 44%

p. 95 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 95 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 95 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page

Top

Find the Perfect Training Class For You